Although three years ago President Bush landed on an aircraft carrier in a Navy fighter jet to a
banner reading "Mission Accomplished," there was little forethought given to exactly what enemy we were indeed fighting in
the Middle East. The “War against Islamo-fascism” was not yet coined and pundits believed that if the root cause
of genocide and tyranny were removed from Baghdad – namely Saddam Hussein – then Iraq would become a symbolic
nation of peace ruled by a Jeffersonian-style democracy. Yet for all of the insight into the military strategy of toppling
a government, one all- important factor was omitted from the analyses: ideology.
Unlike World War II where a global
battle was fought using conventional methods of warfare such as tanks and planes – and even atomic weapons - against
the real threat of fascist Germany and totalitarian Japan, the war
in Iraq is a war against an ideology.
All of the ground troops and air superiority on planet earth cannot dissuade religious adherents from the righteousness of
their cause. This zealous, human need to become a martyr for some “god” has routinely marked most of human history.
Unsoftened by the Epicurean pleasures of entertainment and sexual liberation, extremist Muslims mark a large percent of the
Islamic population as even old women strap suicide bombs to their bodies and encourage their grandchildren to follow their
example if they wish to have a glorious eternity in the hereafter.
Now certainly World War II was also marked by fanatic
adherence to causes such as Nazism, yet the latter was a fledgling ideology which lacked the benefit of centuries of indoctrination
and sectarianism as we see in Islam today. The footprint of Nazi fanaticism was marked by a relative handful of dictatorial
hopefuls in nations where Catholicism and Protestantism held sway for over 15 centuries. And fascism, unlike fanatical Islam,
had one critical flaw in its ideological repertoire, namely that it was not a religion.
For critical observers like
Niccolo Machiavelli in his fascinating work The Prince, religion, rather than some political philosophy, was a tool wielded
by the more effective tyrants. Social and political changes come and go like clouds on the wind, but religious ideology marks
its followers with a resilient, almost indelible stamp upon their very hearts and minds, for religious faith by definition
relies not upon social conventions or analytical social structures but rather upon transcendent belief in what is incalculable
and unquantifiable. When the enemy is some “thing,” a tangible, flesh-and-blood, brick-and-steel creation such
as a soldier or a political regime, the target is simple even if the means of destroying it is difficult. Yet when the enemy
transcends mere mortality, when it is a conceptualization such as a religion, then that target is significantly less substantial,
less easily defined. How does one deploy troops against a fundamentalist theology that has resided in the hearts of a billion
believers for 14 centuries, particularly when that theology instructs its adherents in the righteousness of combating infidels?
I assert that were we given thrice as much time to confront the Islamic insurgency – some would say “civil
war” – in Iraq, we will never
be able to leave a thriving, democratic government in the heart of Islam. In fact, Islam, with its precepts built upon Shariah
law, obligatory prayer and ritual purification, is almost the antithesis of democracy and in cases where democratic-style
governments are in place in the Middle East such as Lebanon and Jordan, they are pale reflections of Western-style democracy,
being wracked by monarchial rule or civil war. And, when presented with a choice of candidates from which to vote, the populace
invariably leans toward electing extremist, fundamentalist groups to lead their nation. I believe that as the years progress,
historians will mark this ensuing period of Iraqi conflict as a sectarian genocide on a scale that would even make Hussein
shudder. And a nation which was hated by groups like Al Qaeda for its secularism will become a fertile breeding ground for
terrorism on a scale never before witnessed.
The solution, if one could ever be said to exist, is absolute and total
martial law with a near 24-hour a day curfew. In the intervening cessation of conflict, security contractors world-wide could
be hired to install a British-like system of high-tech surveillance cameras and face-recognition software to track the movements
of people everywhere. Within a year, Iraqi security and intelligence forces could be background screened and trained to handle
the challenges of enforcing law upon the population, slowly relaxing the curfew until a smoother transition was complete.
Only until law is established and enforced throughout the Iraqi cities and provinces will any government in Iraq succeed in bringing a slow-down in sectarian and civil
violence. Solutions such as those found in the Baker-Hamilton Commission will surely fall short without fresh thinking and
ingenious solutions to the age-old dilemma of combating ideological extremism.
Enter supporting content here
All text and
html coding appearing on www.literarian.org are
intellectual property of the respective
author(s) and are protected under
international copyright laws. The intellectual property
may not be downloaded except
by normal viewing process of the
browser. The intellectual property may not be copied to another
computer, transmitted, published, reproduced, stored,
manipulated, projected, or altered in any way, including without limitation any
digitization or synthesizing of the images, alone or with any other
material, by use of computer or other electronic means or any
other method or means now or hereafter known, without the
written permission of the respective Author(s). By
entering this site, you are agreeing to be bound by the terms of this
agreement. Entrance to this site is
expressly on these conditions which embody
all of the understandings and obligations
between the parties hereto. To
secure reproduction rights to any material here,
and to contact the respective Author(s), send an e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org.