A series of fascinating public television
programs entitled Secrets of the Dead: Mystery of the Black Plague (http://www.pbs.org/wnet/secrets/case_plague/index.html) and Frontline: The Age of AIDS
(http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/aids/) really brought a revelation to me of the importance of random genotropic mutations in
the continual, ongoing evolution of our species. In particular, I refer to the rise of the CCR5-D (delta) 32 allele in Western
Europe and the part it has played in rendering the bacterial Bubonic and Pneumonic Plague and the HIV-1 virus impotent in
causing fatality to the mutation's recipient.
It is a revelation, I say, because proponents of natural selection possess
a nearly irrefutable example of how gradually an organism - in this case, Homo sapiens sapiens - under intense environmental
pressure from microbial diseases can experience change in their genetic structure, the coding for the very proteins which
define a species. (http://ib.berkeley.edu/labs/slatkin/novembre/GalvaniNovembreMicInf2005.pdf)
The explosion of the delta32 mutation among human populations of Western Europe
(a mutation of uniquely Scandinavian origin roughly 2000 years ago) was brought about by environmental pressure beginning
with the introduction of the plague in Italy in about 1347. Geneticists have proved today that those individuals with the
CCR5-D32 deletion mutation on one chromosome still contracted the disease but successfully recovered, while those carrying
the mutation on both chromosomes were virtually immune to the plague's effects.
Interestingly enough, HIV-1 virus
attacks the immune system (T-cells receptors) in nearly the same manner as the plague, even though the former is a virus and
the latter is a bacterium. Individuals who possess the CCR5-D32 mutation also show a heightened resistance to the HIV virus
and even immunity in some cases. Because of these two infectious agents over a nearly 700-year period, estimates place the
frequency of the mutation between 10 and 20 percent among human populations of European descent.
Today, given that
the Black Death was relatively uncommon among the inhabitants of continents like Africa and Asia and among Native Americans
in the New World, individuals from these ethnicities exposed to the HIV-1 virus are 1) more likely to contract it and 2) more
likely to die from it once contracted.
Although the relative frequency of the CCR5-D32 deletion mutation is negligible
among inhabitants of Africa and Asia, those few individuals who may have somehow inherited the mutation through a European
ancestor will prove more likely to survive the AIDS pandemic, thereby increasing the incidence of the mutation even on these
continents. I suspect that as the fatal HIV virus runs its course in the decades ahead (as all deadly pathogens eventually
do), natural selection will globally favor those individuals who possess the mutation and its frequency in the human genome
will continue to increase significantly.
Whether future unforeseen pandemics will place further environmental pressure
favoring selection of the D32 mutation until the deletion becomes the genetic "rule" rather than the exception cannot be known
with certainly; yet one thing that can be said with a measure of absolutism is that regardless of how far our technology and
social institutions evolve, nature will continue to exert its influence on our species, subtle or otherwise. Natural selection
is a real and vibrant force that will continue to operate as long as our planet can sustain viable life, enacting its own
version, comparatively speaking, of genetic "uniformitarianism" and "catastrophism."
So, why is any of this important?
We as a species stand upon the threshold of genetic determinism, soon possessing both the ability and the will to construct
through gene splicing future generations of Homo sapiens sapiens. We will have the ability to splice genes for selected
benefits such as intelligence and coordination while splicing-out genes that may predispose our descendents to diseases like
Alzheimer’s and diabetes. Still, for all the technological and medical precision we are developing, we may actually
end up removing "bad" genes from our progeny's gene pool that may actually ward against new and deadly diseases such as HIV.
Let's say that it's 100 years
in the future, the turn of the 22nd century, and it is not uncommon for most couples and individuals desiring to have
a child to have their chromosomes spliced and arranged so that the subsequent off-spring is relatively healthy and devoid
of most bad genes. Additionally, let's assume that one of those bad genes, we'll call it the XYZ-Alpha mutation, causes
humans to stop producing an enzyme that may cause pimples on the skin. We don't, after all, in a world where we can
create our perfect children, want they to have unseemly skin blemishes; that may cause them to be ridiculed and teased in
school. So, in this hypothetical example, it is standard operating procedure (excuse the pun) to remove any occurrence
of this mutation from the gene-splicing procedure. Except for those who are destined by poverty or simple choice to
have children the "natural" way (this will become increasingly viewed as a Medieval and Draconian method of creating
offspring, to be sure), all other children will be genetically free of unseemly mutations and, therefore, less genetically
diverse. Then, it happens. An arrival on the scene of a wholly new form of virus called, for argumentative purposes,
Interestingly enough, this new
ABC virus attacks receptors on the XYZ allele, resulting in the prolonged and painful wasting away of the human victim from
the outside in. It is spread in a variety of ways but is primarily a blood-borne pathogen that is exchanged through
the transmission of body fluids. It began in developing nations and has been transmitted to three continents before
the World Health Organization was able to identify the disease. Since the virus has a dormancy period of 10
to 20 years, health officials have no idea what the true infection rate is since the dormant virus does not
appear in any currently used blood pathogen tests.
In no time at all, wealthy, gene-spliced,
jet-setting adults and children alike have contracted the disease both on vacations and on selfless humanitarian missions
overseas, bringing the disease home with them and spreading it among the general population as well as their gene-spliced
peers with whom they typically socialize choose as mates (class begets class). These near perfect, attractive, intellectually
and physically gifted individuals are decimated by a disease that spares few who do not have the XYZ-Alpha mutation.
In essence, because of the lack of foresight of those who would genetically recombine humans so that they are void of predisposition
to diseases and other bad genes, attempts to create whole, healthy children leads inadvertently to their death.
As we develop the techniques and
the expertise to create gene-spliced offspring, I believe that we should consider our choices and weigh the potentialities
with the inherent risk of the unforeseen. Just because we possess the ability and the power to do something does
not necessarily mean that we should do it, at least not after
careful deliberation and an ongoing, global forum on the ethical implementation of technology, particularly that which could
alter the very evolution of our species.
All text is copyright protected and remains the sole intellectual property
of the Author. Any reproduction of the material from this site for either public or private use is strictly prohibited.
Requests for reproduction of the aforementioned work(s) may be sent via e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org Such requests are not guaranteed unless expressly authorized in writing by
the Originator prior to any use by the requestor(s). Bioethics, HIV, and the Black Death, Copyright 2008.
All text and
html coding appearing on www.literarian.org are
intellectual property of the respective
author(s) and are protected under
international copyright laws. The intellectual property
may not be downloaded except
by normal viewing process of the
browser. The intellectual property may not be copied to another
computer, transmitted, published, reproduced, stored,
manipulated, projected, or altered in any way, including without limitation any
digitization or synthesizing of the images, alone or with any other
material, by use of computer or other electronic means or any
other method or means now or hereafter known, without the
written permission of the respective Author(s). By
entering this site, you are agreeing to be bound by the terms of this
agreement. Entrance to this site is
expressly on these conditions which embody
all of the understandings and obligations
between the parties hereto. To
secure reproduction rights to any material here,
and to contact the respective Author(s), send an e-mail to email@example.com.